Our approach
How we assess research
Looking carefully at what research tells us, and where questions remain.
Looking beyond the label
We look at the research behind products and their claims, including clinical studies of the finished product when they are available. Clinical testing can provide valuable information, but it is not a guarantee of effectiveness.
We consider how a study was conducted, who funded it, whether findings have been repeated independently, how large the effect was and whether the outcome is relevant to the concern being addressed.
Research and commercial interests
A Cochrane review of studies on medicines and medical devices found that industry-sponsored studies more often reported results and conclusions favourable to the sponsor than studies with other sources of funding. This does not mean that every industry-funded study has been manipulated. Influence can be more subtle, for example through the choice of comparison, what is measured or how results are interpreted.
A lack of research can also reflect financial incentives. A company may have little reason to fund a thorough study if it cannot recover the costs. This can be especially relevant for inexpensive, generic or non-patentable products. Claims that a particular product’s research was actively prevented by lobbying groups would need specific evidence.
When research is limited
When no study is available, a product’s effectiveness remains uncertain. Some natural remedies have been used for centuries, and we consider this history of use alongside the research that is available. Traditional use can offer a starting point for understanding a remedy, while questions about its effects and safety may remain.
We will always be transparent about what we know, what we don’t yet know and the reasons behind our assessments.
Reference
Lundh, A., Lexchin, J., Mintzes, B., Schroll, J. B., & Bero, L. (2017). Industry sponsorship and research outcome. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2017(2), MR000033. Read the review ↗
← Back to the Evidonne Score